collaboratories:
conservation roadmap

Our Collaboratories co-produce durable conservation solutions by connecting science, management, and policy with local action.

Our Conservation Roadmap Collaboratory is working to shift federal conservation priorities away from approaches that entrench division, and toward strategies that build on historical gains with more flexible, durable, and collaborative opportunities.

Publications

Durability by Design

Lessons on How to Design Conservation Policies, Programs, and Projects That Survive Political Change

Authored by Robert Bonnie, former United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) Undersecretary & Stone Center Distinguished Scholar

The whiplash that greets each new presidential administration has become one of today’s great challenges for American conservation. Policies enacted with great effort under one administration are rolled back by the next, only to be partially restored when the political winds shift again. The cycle consumes enormous resources—resources that conservation groups and their funders must spend defending yesterday’s victories instead of investing in tomorrow’s opportunities. More fundamentally, it prevents the kind of long-term, adaptive stewardship that healthy ecosystems require.

The durability problem is not simply a product of partisan polarization beyond our control. It is also, to a significant degree, a product of choices that conservation advocates make—about whom we engage, how we build coalitions, what policy tools we choose, and how we design programs for implementation. Durability must be designed.

No conservation effort is impregnable to change. Indeed, the second Trump Administration has sought to undo and defund many popular conservation policies and initiatives, including many that have broad support. Even so, there are lessons to be gleaned from past experience, conservation experts and the academic literature about how to design durable conservation policy, programs, and initiatives that can survive political pendulum swings.

The observations and conclusions herein draw on research into specific conservation policies and programs that have demonstrated durability—some surviving both Republican and Democratic Congresses and administrations, others building coalitions so broad that political reversal became much more difficult. They also draw on interviews with over 20 experienced conservation practitioners and policymakers whose collective experience spans federal agencies, Congress, state government, and the private sector. Their candor and insight have shaped this chapter.

The examples examined here span a wide range: federal legislation like the Great American Outdoors Act and the Land and Water Conservation Fund; protected area designations in Idaho, New Mexico, and Maine; state conservation funding programs in Alabama and South Carolina; voluntary private lands initiatives like NRCS’s Sage Grouse Initiative; place-based collaborative governance models like the Blackfoot Challenge; campaigns such as the effort to protect Bristol Bay; and cross-administration federal programs like DOI’s Secretarial Order 3362 on big game migration corridors. Across these very different types of conservation action, a consistent set of factors distinguishes what lasts from what doesn’t.

This chapter argues that durable conservation policy, programs and projects is first built on appealing to stakeholders’ values in conserving the places, wildlife and natural resources they care about. Designing conservation in a way that provides economic benefits to communities is also critical.

Building coalitions, partnerships and collaboratives is vital to the durability of policy, programs and projects and is a common theme throughout. Advocates must take the time – sometimes years – to build broad, diverse and bipartisan support for conservation. Successful programs and policies are also developed with meaningful input from stakeholders and are designed in a way that is both effective and self-reinforcing. Implementation of conservation policy and programs requires that agencies and other partners have the staffing, relationships and funding to last.

Part I: Appeal to Values Bolstered by Economics

The most fundamental insight from this research is deceptively simple: durable conservation is built on shared values. When conservation advocates lead with ideological arguments, propose polarizing approaches, or focus on conflict, they repel potential allies. When advocates start from the values that nearly all Americans share—clean water, healthy wildlife populations, places to hunt and fish, landscapes that define community identity—they are more likely to find partners.

“Conservation needs to be aligned with the values of key stakeholders. To last, conservation has to be embedded in community.” —Adam Snyder, The Nature Conservancy

The conservation community is not suffering from a values deficit among the American public. Polling consistently shows that conservation crosses partisan lines—Americans of all political persuasions support clean water, healthy wildlife, and access to outdoor recreation. For example, Colorado College has polled 8 western inland states for 16 years and found consistent and overwhelming support for conservation. The problem is that conservation advocates have sometimes pursued policies that feel disconnected from those values, or that impose costs on communities without delivering visible local benefits. Rural voters, for example, while often strongly supportive of conservation, can be resistant to approaches perceived as top-down or overly centralized, particularly when they raise concerns about federal overreach and reduced local control.

When advocates inadvertently turn off these constituents, conservation loses the very people and organizations it needs for long-term durability. This is an important point. Science tells us that success in conserving the nation’s land, water and biodiversity requires conserving large landscapes across public, private and tribal lands. This means success is predicated on our ability to work across diverse stakeholders, including farmers, ranchers, forest landowners, tribes, state and local governments and many others.

Taylor Schmitz of the Congressional Sportsmen’s Foundation makes a related point. He believes that efforts to restrict public land access—including Senator Mike Lee’s amendment that proposed selling federal lands—fail not primarily because of economic arguments against them, but because they are fundamentally out of step with what most Americans value. “Economics of conservation are important,” Schmitz says, “but values are more important.” People value hunting and fishing and recreation on public lands. Policy that threatens those uses will face durable opposition regardless of the economic arguments made for it.

“There is something magical about the ability to brand an ecosystem in a way that appeals to the human soul.” –David O’Neill, President and CEO of Mass Audubon

Tommy Beaudreau, former Deputy Secretary of the Interior, frames the values question in practical terms. Conservation that lasts, he argues, is conservation of “real places that matter to real people.” This is why the Cecil Andrus–White Clouds Wilderness in Idaho and the Organ Mountains–Desert Peaks National Monument in New Mexico have proven durable—they protect landscapes that are woven into the identity of their surrounding communities. When then-Secretary of the Interior Ryan Zinke came to review the Organ Mountains monument in 2017 on a visit many feared would foreshadow action to undo the designation, he found a community with strong cultural and economic ties to the monument. Undoing the monument or reducing its size would have meant taking something away from people who valued it deeply. Secretary Zinke chose not to.

Building a robust coalition for establishment of monuments around common values is far more difficult when designations are rushed – as many are – at the end of an outgoing Presidential Administration. Without dedicating the time-consuming and significant investments necessary to build broad stakeholder support, it may mean conservationists are required to spend money and time defending those designations for years. It also means that constituencies that may have been persuadable are lost, also potentially for years. The simple answer is to start coalition building earlier and to use discretion regarding when to move a proposal. Moreover, in all cases, advocates should recognize that a designation is not the end of their work – continued effort is needed to build and sustain local support and to ensure that agencies have the necessary resources to support administration and management of the site.

Appealing to stakeholder values is equally important when working with tribal nations and interests. As former Director of USDA’s office of Tribal Relations, now with World Wildlife Fund and member of the Cheyenne River Sioux Tribe, HeatherDawn Thompson, describes: given tribes’ historic connection to the land: “U.S. tribal nations are a good bet for conservation.” Still, tribal values are unique. Restoring the buffalo, for example, for many tribes is about far more than just conservation; it takes on issues related to food sovereignty, self-sufficiency and spiritual values. Thompson also notes that tribal lands are often embedded in deep red parts of the country where tribal members form bonds with their neighbors, meaning that political affiliations are more nuanced than might be assumed.

Economics Still Matter

While appealing to values is critical, the economic impacts of conservation policies and actions are important, too. Conservation actions are much more likely to endure when they create concrete economic benefits for the communities and landowners most directly affected. In some cases, those benefits may be avoiding costs to a community by, for example, conserving habitat for wildlife in some areas that might allow development in others. Former Deputy Secretary Beaudreau frames the economic test as “making sure we’re not taking food off someone’s table.” When conservation imposes real economic costs on local communities without providing compensating benefits, it generates durable opposition. When it creates economic opportunities—for recreation businesses, outfitters, farmers, and ranchers who are rewarded for stewardship, and local 4 suppliers—it generates durable support. Will Shafroth, who served in the Obama Administration and formerly led the National Park Foundation, notes the importance of gateway communities around parks whose economies are tied to the conservation and stewardship of the Parks and surrounding areas.

Economics mattered for the decision to maintain the Organ Mountains–Desert Peaks monument. When Secretary Zinke conducted his monument review in 2017, the monument had three years of visitation data and a documented economic impact to present. The combination of overwhelming public comment and concrete economic evidence made reduction politically untenable, even though Governor Susana Martinez and Rep. Steve Pearce actively sought it. By 2025, the monument had accumulated a decade of economic impact data showing $234 million in cumulative economic benefit and a nearly fourfold increase in visitation—making the political case for protection substantially stronger than it was in 2017.

Jess Wahl Turner of the Outdoor Recreation Roundtable emphasizes a related point: conservation projects that leverage non-government dollars tend to be more durable because they create tangible local buy-in. When private businesses and local organizations have made their own financial commitments to a conservation area or program, they have a direct economic stake in its continuation.

While Turner’s point draws on her experience with outdoor recreation, local resources can also prove important in very different contexts. Though it was once met with strong local opposition in Maine, the Katahdin Woods and Waters monument benefited enormously from the $40 million private endowment contributed by the Elliotsville Foundation, which meant the NPS could stand up operations, hire staff, and deliver visible economic results quickly—accelerating the conversion of local opinion from opposition to support.

Evidence of the significant economic benefits from conservation is made more compelling when it is humanized through storytelling that links those benefits to real people. In 2025, to highlight his work with USDA on the Migratory Big Game Initiative in the Greater Yellowstone Ecosystem, Wyoming Governor Mark Gordon toured ranches in the Shoshone River Valley where one rancher noted that incentives from the Initiative made it possible for one of his children to move back to the ranch and join him in the family business.

Focusing on Where Interests Intersect

Meryl Harrell, former Deputy Under Secretary for Natural Resources and the Environment at USDA, puts this directly: the question conservation advocates should ask is not where are the “trade-offs and balance” between competing interests, but instead where do those interests actually intersect? This is a fundamentally different kind of question—it asks conservation advocates to look for the policies and programs that genuinely serve multiple constituencies rather than those that simply split differences between them.

In the mid-1990s and in the wake of the spotted owl wars in the Pacific Northwest, landowners in the South feared that regulations to protect the endangered red-cockaded woodpecker would devastate the southern pine industry. Knowing the importance of privately-owned, mature longleaf pine forests to the bird, Michael Bean, then director of the wildlife program at Environmental Defense Fund, started looking for landowner 5 groups with shared interests. He formed an alliance with the North Carolina Pine Needle Producers Association, a group that represented businesses and landowners who rake longleaf pine needles and sell them by the bale for mulch. Michael Bean and Jerry Holder, the Association’s President, worked together to advocate for longleaf pine forests and the businesses that rely on them. The partnership helped lead to the development of the first Safe Harbor Agreement for the woodpecker – those agreements have contributed to the downlisting of the bird to threatened under the ESA.

Michael Bean’s work sought to find unique partnerships that could propel conservation. Trout Unlimited’s Tim Bristol, one of the architects of the campaign to protect Bristol Bay, calls this “creating as many on-ramps as you can with people.” Amy Sobel, a co-founder of Thunderbird Strategies with extensive working lands experience, adds that authentic engagement with rural landowners requires “real listening not lip service.” On private working lands, she emphasizes, it’s essential to “jointly problem-solve” rather than arrive with pre-formed solutions. The difference between those two modes of engagement is usually visible to landowners and other stakeholders immediately—and it can determine whether they become partners or adversaries.

Part II: Durable Coalitions by Design

The second foundational element of durable conservation is the breadth and depth of the stakeholder coalition that supports it. A coalition composed primarily of environmental organizations and Democratic elected officials may be sufficient to achieve an initial conservation victory—but it may lack the strength to protect that goal when the political environment changes. Likewise, a coalition that is comprised largely of national organizations – particularly for issues that have a strong local or regional bent – may struggle when Administrations change. The coalitions that produce durable conservation consistently include constituencies that reach across partisan lines and include voices from the communities most directly affected.

“My job is to make success politically inevitable.” —Rick Johnson, former CEO, Idaho Conservation League

Rick Johnson, who played a central role in the decade-and-a-half effort to protect the Boulder–White Clouds, describes his approach with characteristic directness. Making success politically inevitable means building a coalition so broad and so deeply rooted that opposition becomes politically costly for all sides. By the time the Boulder–White Clouds bill finally passed in 2015, its supporters included the Idaho Farm Bureau, the Idaho Cattle Association, Idaho Outfitters and Guides, the Idaho Recreation Council (representing snowmobilers and motorcyclists), the Idaho Conservation League, the Wilderness Society, and the Sierra Club. Talk of President Obama using a monument designation motivated many of these stakeholders to press harder for legislation for fear that the authorities under the Antiquities Act might not be nimble enough to preserve the hard-fought consensus. The bill passed the Senate by unanimous consent. Additionally, funders – such as Pew Charitable Trust – provided critical long-term support that sustained IDL and other coalition members’ work during a lengthy campaign.

Idaho has another lesson to offer. When President Trump announced his intent to repeal the 2001 Roadless Rule, he exempted roadless protections in Idaho and the state of 6 Colorado. Both states had developed their own, state-specific rules and both rules were developed through an extensive stakeholder process. Both eased some roadless protections to allow for limited forest management to reduce the threat of wildfire around communities embedded in Forest Service lands. Both state-based rules also placed large areas of land under stronger protections than the 2001 rule. Most importantly, both had strong local support. When Trump sought to repeal roadless protections, Senator Risch, who negotiated the Idaho rule as Governor, demanded that the Administration leave his rule alone. To date, the Administration has done that for both states.

The Republican Champion Is Often the Critical Variable

Across the cases examined in this research, the presence or absence of a credible Republican champion—a conservative elected official or community leader who can defend a conservation initiative in terms that resonate with conservative constituencies—is often an important predictor of whether a conservation initiative proves durable.

The campaign in opposition to the Pebble Mine in Bristol Bay mobilized broad opposition from indigenous groups, commercial fishing, sport fishermen, tourism interests and conservation groups, laying the foundation for both Alaska Republican Senators to oppose the mine.

Rep. Mike Simpson (R-ID) spent fifteen years shepherding the Boulder–White Clouds legislation precisely because he was the right messenger for the right community. A conservative Idaho Republican who had served as Speaker of the Idaho House, Simpson gave the wilderness bill a political identity that could not be caricatured as a federal “land grab.” His partnership with Rick Johnson—what Johnson calls an “unlikely odd couple”—is a model for the kind of cross-partisan alliance that can foster broad support for conservation actions.

Similarly, the Great American Outdoors Act, which became law in 2020, owes much of its durability to the fact that it was championed by Senators Cory Gardner (R-CO) and Steve Daines (R-MT) and signed by President Trump. When the second Trump administration proposed diverting the Land and Water Conservation Fund (LWCF) funding in 2025, the conservation community was able to argue—with justification—that doing so would undercut “President Trump’s own conservation legacy.” That framing complicated the administration’s position in ways that Democratic advocacy alone would likely not have achieved.

Bruce Knight, former USDA Under Secretary and Chief of NRCS during the George W. Bush Presidency, points to an encouraging recent trend: the emergence of center-right organizations that are explicitly pro-conservation. While sportsmen groups have been critical to conservation advocacy since the late 1800s, Knight is referring to groups that represent conservative think-tanks, farmers and ranchers, other rural landowners, outdoor recreation businesses and others. These recognized and friendly stakeholder groups give conservative politicians a stronger rationale for supporting conservation initiatives. Cultivating long-term relationships with these organizations built on aligned interests could prove important in building a broad center in support of more durable conservation policies and programs.

Coalition-Building Takes Time and Requires Leadership

One of the most consistent findings from the cases examined here is that durable conservation coalitions are built over years or decades, not months. The Boulder–White Clouds took fifteen years. The Organ Mountains–Desert Peaks monument rested on more than a decade of community organizing before President Obama designated it in 2014. The campaign to oppose the Pebble Mine took shape in the early 2010s and was able to combine indigenous groups, commercial fishing interests, recreational anglers, and conservation groups. The Katahdin Woods and Waters monument, which initially faced intense local opposition, took years of post-designation community engagement before local business leaders and eventually Senator Susan Collins herself became champions of the designation. The Black Bear Conservation Committee (BBCC), established in 1992 when the Louisiana Black Bear was listed as threatened under the Endangered Species Act, operated for nearly twenty-five years before the bear was delisted in 2016.

Extended timelines are often necessary to develop the relationships and trust that leads to meaningful and durable conservation outcomes. Murray Lloyd, co-founder of the BBCC, understood from the beginning that the effort could take twenty years, and that keeping diverse stakeholders engaged for that long required deliberate social investment. The “Southern Rules of Engagement” he established for the Committee—including the requirement to “come to the table,” “leave your organizational two-by-four at the door,” “pick solutions, not fights,” and “have fun”—were not casual guidelines. They were a systematic approach to building the relationships that would carry the coalition through decades of sustained work.

Jimmy Bullock, Senior Vice President for Forest Sustainability for RMS and a leader in the BBCC and subsequent wildlife conservation efforts, echoes the same insight: “Create a culture of collaboration so we don’t have to fight each other and can instead solve problems.” The goal of long-term coalition investment is to make conflict resolution the default mode of the coalition, not an emergency response to crisis. When the culture of collaboration is established and maintained, the coalition can absorb political pressure without fracturing.

It is an obvious but important point: durable coalitions require clear leadership, whether from conservation groups or other individuals and organizations. Such leadership is critical to building consensus around important issues, adapting to new circumstances and opportunities over time, and defending conservation gains when necessary. Such leadership also often requires sustained financial resources from conservation funders who recognize that building relationships and durable networks takes much longer than a few grant cycles or political cycles. Investments in future conservation leaders – “bench strength” as one conservation leader put it – is also critical to building durable coalitions.

Process Must Be Transparent and Genuinely Responsive

Coalition-building fails when stakeholders feel that their engagement is performative rather than substantive. Meryl Harrell is direct about this: the policy or project design must actually reflect the ideas surfaced from stakeholder engagement – and those stakeholders must be representative of the affected communities and not just DC-based organizations. When it does not—when communities feel that the outcome was 8 predetermined and their input was window dressing—the result is a coalition in name only, one that will dissolve under pressure.

Lindsay Slater, who served as a staffer for Congressman Simpson during the Boulder–White Clouds effort, describes the approach that finally produced a durable result: “We nailed down all the problems up front.” The bill addressed nearly every concern that had been raised by every significant constituency—before the bill was introduced. The result was a bill that had genuine buy-in from all its supporters because they had each shaped it.

Suzanne Dixon, a co-founder of Thunderbird Strategies with 25 years of conservation experience, puts the same principle succinctly: “Durability must be designed.” It does not simply emerge organically —it must be intentionally built into the structure of the coalition, the policy, and the implementation plan.

Sometimes Conflict is Inevitable

There are, of course, conservation issues where conflict may be inevitable and a negotiated compromise is not possible. Take the debate over the last decade surrounding the proposed copper mine near the border from the Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness in Minnesota. The proposed copper-sulfate mine immediately upstream from the nation’s most visited wilderness area is unlikely to be resolved through a collaborative stakeholder process. Still, even in places like the Boundary Waters, diverse, bipartisan, locally-based coalitions are critical. The campaign to defeat Pebble Mine, for example, demonstrates that a long, locally-based, well-funded campaign that mobilizes diverse, bipartisan stakeholders can prove decisive.

Notably, the vast majority of challenges facing conservation aren’t as binary as the Boundary Waters and Pebble Mine; indeed, the vast majority could benefit from collaboration across diverse stakeholders. Yet, sometimes advocates treat all issues as if confrontation is the only approach. Taylor Schmitz notes that it’s important that advocates not treat every issue “as if it’s San Juan Hill.” Moreover, perhaps by building broader, longer lasting coalitions on a variety of conservation issues, those relationships may serve conservation advocates when they are confronted with efforts to weaken protections around places such as the Boundary Waters.

One question is whether there are enough solution-oriented people to build durable coalitions in all landscapes and regions. What if there is deep-seeded opposition among local stakeholders and even attempting to build local support for conservation seems fruitless? In the mid-1990s, Dougald McCormick, patriarch of a family that owned a tract of pristine longleaf pine adjacent to Fort Bragg military base in North Carolina, would have surely counted himself among the strongest opponents of conserving the endangered red-cockaded woodpecker in this federally-designated recovery area. Indeed, McCormick’s beat-up pick-up truck had a licence plate reading “I EAT RCWS.” And, yet, even McCormick was swayed by local efforts to create the first Safe Harbor agreement that provided him and other landowners an incentive to manage lands to conserve the very bird his cheeky license plate mocked. Under the agreement, McCormick and others agreed to long-term management for the bird while the US Fish and Wildlife Service agreed to effectively freeze their regulatory liability under the Endangered Species Act. Indeed, McCormick became one of the first landowners to enroll in the program, saying “I want to see this succeed.” That North Carolina program 9 spawned similar programs in other states that have conserved hundreds of breeding pairs of RCWs. Building local and regional support for conservation is more than possible in the vast majority of places.

Part III: Engage Coalitions and Partners to Design Policies and Programs That Are Structurally Durable

The third element of durable conservation is the design of policies and programs themselves. Even a broad, well-constructed coalition cannot protect a policy that is poorly conceived or is economically disconnected from the communities it affects. The first three sections below address policies and programs on public, private and then tribal lands. The subject policies and programs emerged from interviews and research and present examples of effective and durable approaches. A critical element in the success of these examples stems from the discussion above: bringing those affected by policy into the design process. Stakeholder involvement in policy and program design results in better and more durable solutions. The section then addresses funding for land conservation at the local, state and federal levels. While it may be obvious, policies that invest taxpayer dollars in land conservation are overwhelmingly popular. Finally, the section concludes by discussing how policies and programs can be designed to create positive feedback loops that reinforce conservation success.

On Management of Public Lands, Empowering Collaboratives to Design Land Management Plans and Restoration Projects Shows Promise

When the US Forest Service was founded in 1905, Chief Gifford Pinchot and other progressives largely believed that foresters in the new agency would use their expertise to manage forests on behalf of the public. Beginning in the 1960s, the public demanded a stronger voice in public lands management – not trusting an agency left to its own devices. Over the last several decades and thanks to legislation passed in the late 1960s and 1970s, a new model has emerged on Forest Service and other public lands that vests far more power outside the agency to develop management plans and projects. More recently, the development of “collaboratives” has become critical to public lands management and will likely influence management of these lands for decades to come.

The Four Forest Restoration Initiative (4FRI) in northern Arizona offers an instructive example of how a well-designed collaborative process can produce a durable land management plan on public forests and persist, even as implementation of that plan encountered serious hurdles. Spanning 2.4 million acres across the Kaibab, Coconino, Apache-Sitgreaves, and Tonto National Forests, 4FRI represents what the Forest Service called “unprecedented stakeholder engagement and participation.”

In the wake of large wildfires in the region, 4FRI was formed following a series of joint landscape assessments and wood supply studies that anchored the coalition in shared science. The coalition that eventually signed onto “The Path Forward”—4FRI’s foundational consensus document—included the Center for Biological Diversity, The Nature Conservancy, the timber industry, county governments, water utilities, and state 10 agencies. That combination produced a 2-million-acre land use plan that has had no meaningful litigation challenges.

Following adoption of the plan, 4FRI was hampered by weak timber markets that made forest restoration expensive and challenging. Still, by Fiscal Year 2024, 4FRI had become the Forest Service’s most productive Wildfire Crisis Strategy landscape, treating over 200,000 acres and accounting for 25% of the total acres treated nationally across all high-risk landscapes.

The federal government effectively institutionalized the same collaborative approach used in 4FRI through the Collaborative Forest Landscape Restoration Program, established by Congress in 2009. CFLRP has now funded 31 landscape-scale restoration projects across 14 states, restoring more than 6.7 million acres—an area the size of Massachusetts—through collaborative processes involving Forest Service employees, local governments, timber industry, conservation organizations, tribes, and community partners.

CFLRP requires that all projects be planned and carried out through a collaborative process. Since 2011, CFLRP investments have supported an annual average of $213 million in local labor income and 4,900 jobs. Based on a 2025 US Forest Service report, when wildfires have interacted with previously treated CFLRP landscapes, fire suppression staff reported that the treatments helped control or moderate fire behavior 83% of the time.

Authorized under Obama, CFLRP was reauthorized and its funding doubled in the 2018 Farm Bill under Trump—championed by a bipartisan Senate coalition including Senators Merkley (D-OR) and Crapo (R-ID). Additional funding came through the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law under Biden. In May 2025, Senators Merkley and Crapo again teamed up to introduce the bipartisan CFLRP Reauthorization Act of 2025, with companion House legislation introduced jointly by Congressman Neguse (D-CO) and Congressman Zinke (R-MT).

On Working Lands, Voluntary, Incentive-Based Approaches Delivered through Partnerships at Scale

More than 60 percent of the US is privately owned and much of this acreage is “working” ranch, farm and forest land. Given the importance of these lands to a range of conservation goals, including rare species conservation, water conservation and climate mitigation, well designed working lands conservation strategies are crucial. On these lands, regulations are insufficient and sometimes even counterproductive to encourage necessary management actions, whereas various forms of technical and financial assistance that are more flexible can play a catalytic role. The challenge on working lands has always been how to scale across large landscapes.

Just as there has been significant innovation on public lands management in the last several decades, so too has there been significant innovation on working lands conservation. Indeed, nearly 40 million acres of US land has been permanently conserved through voluntary conservation easements, fueled by incentives in federal and state tax codes as well as government programs, such as those operated by NRCS and US Fish and Wildlife Service, that provide strong monetary incentives for land conservation. National organizations such as Ducks Unlimited and The Nature Conservancy and state 11 and local land trusts have worked alone or in partnership with state and federal agencies to enroll landowners and help steward easements once lands are enrolled.

Beyond easements alone, there has been significant innovation in working lands conservation over the last three decades. The NRCS Sage Grouse Initiative is perhaps the clearest illustration. Launched in 2010 under the threat of an ESA listing for the bird, the SGI sought to conserve and restore habitat across eleven Western states through incentive-based approaches funded by the Farm Bill. By 2015, the program had enrolled 1,129 ranchers conserving 5.6 million acres—contributing significantly to the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service’s determination at that time that the greater sage-grouse did not warrant listing. The program has continued to grow: NRCS’s most recent scorecard documents more than 10.5 million acres under contract across over 3,000 ranches.

The DOI Secretarial Order 3362 on big game migration corridors and the USDA Migratory Big Game Initiative follow the same design logic: voluntary participation, incentive-based programs, respect for private property rights, and a deliberate partnership with state wildlife agencies. Each has demonstrated durability across administrations of both parties. S.O. 3362, signed by the first Trump administration in 2018, was continued during the Biden administration years. Likewise, the Migratory Big Game Initiative begun during the Biden Administration has been embraced by the second Trump administration, which in June 2026 issued a new Migratory Big Game Framework. Ultimately, these policies will steer hundreds of millions of dollars to conservation of migration corridors through conservation easements, a new conservation leasing program, fencing upgrades, habitat restoration, and nonlethal conflict management for wolves and bears.

One area where there has been some disagreement on migration policy is concerning the advisability of land designations. “Drawing lines on maps” often brings concerns about regulatory overreach and can thus spur strong local opposition. If, on the other hand, designation of corridors is perceived by stakeholders as coming with additional resources and incentives for landowners (as has been the case in parts of Greater Yellowstone), then attitudes change.

Opportunities Working with Tribes

Just as there has been significant innovation in conservation of public and private lands over the last few decades, so too has there been on tribal lands. Of course, stewardship has been practiced on tribal lands for millennia. Prescribed fire – or cultural burning – has a long history on tribal lands and for tribes like the Tule River, it has proven important in conserving fire dependent species such as giant sequoia. Indeed, a primary goal of programs like CFLRP is to reintroduce and mimic native Americans’ historic use of fire. Likewise, the restoration of the bison – and other endangered wildlife – to the western plains has been led by tribes, including the Confederated Salish and Kootenai Tribes, the InterTribal Buffalo Council and the Wind River Reservation.

HeatherDawn Thompson emphasizes the opportunity for durable conservation on tribal lands because the legal structure of trust lands promotes durability, and tribal culture and spirituality promotes intergenerational commitment. New partnerships between tribes and the federal government also hold promise for long-term conservation. Co-stewardship agreements developed between the Bureau of Land Management and US Forest Service, in particular, have advanced conservation and restoration of public lands across millions of acres. As with the examples above for public and private lands, durable work with tribes is about engagement and partnership.

Funding for Land and Easement Acquisition – Even in Deep Red States – Has Broad Support

Nationally and even in very conservative states, public support for providing taxpayers dollars for land acquisition and conservation easements as well as water infrastructure and conservation is robust.

State-level programs —such as Alabama’s Forever Wild and the South Carolina Conservation Bank—illustrate how constitutional amendment and dedicated funding mechanisms can create durability at the state level. Forever Wild’s 84 percent approval in 1992 and 75 percent re-approval in 2012 established a strong public mandate for conservation. The SC Conservation Bank’s more complicated story—institutionally permanent since 2018, but financially precarious since its dedicated deed recording fee was eliminated—illustrates that legal authorization and financial security are distinct vulnerabilities, and that the loss of dedicated funding can be a real threat. In 2025 in Texas, voters overwhelmingly passed Proposition 4, creating dedicated funding for water infrastructure including everything from desalination to aging pipe repair to flood mitigation – suggesting that addressing water supplies and infrastructure is broadly popular.

Local and municipal conservation finance ballot measures have also proven to be very successful. An analysis by University of Colorado post-doc Cassidy Buhler and colleagues examined 3,000 ballot initiatives from 1988 and 2025 and found that these measures passed at high and statistically equivalent rates in both Democratic and Republican leaning jurisdictions.

Just as there is bipartisan support for funding land and conservation easement acquisition at the state and local levels, there is also – albeit somewhat more tenuous – bipartisan support for the same at the federal level. As noted above, the permanent reauthorization of the LWCF and passage of the Great American Outdoors Act were passed with broad bipartisan support and signed by President Trump during his first Administration. In 2025, Congress added unspent Farm Bill conservation program dollars from the Inflation Reduction Act to the permanent Farm Bill conservation budget baseline.

There are clearly voices within the Republican party – certainly some in the political appointees currently serving at the Office of Management and Budget – who are opposed to additional funding for acquisition of land and conservation easements. It’s worth asking whether conservation strategies and campaigns that are easily characterized as federal lands grabs – in part because they lack input and support from diverse constituencies – fuel opposition from such ideologues.

Still, the continued broad, bipartisan public support appears to be durable, and Congress appears more likely to adhere to its constituents’ desires than more ideological voices within the Republican coalition. Recent evidence of this bipartisan support is reflected in strong backing from both House and Senate Appropriations Committee members for the Trump Administration’s submission of the FY26 and FY27 Land and Water Conservation Fund project lists at the fully authorized $900 million level. In contrast, the same pattern 13 is not apparent on issues around land use regulation, restrictions on the use of public lands or other regulatory approaches. This is not to suggest that regulatory approaches are always problematic. As noted previously, regulation will remain a critical tool. But, it does suggest that when there is a choice of policy instruments to advance conservation, non-regulatory approaches are more likely to garner broader political support and, thus, to be durable.

“Durability comes from systems that connect policy to funding to implementation. Local capacity drives durability.” —Suzanne Dixon, Thunderbird Strategies

Policies That Create Positive Feedback Loops Are Self-Reinforcing

Durable conservation programs often are those that generate the constituencies needed to defend them through the act of implementation. Economists call this a positive feedback loop; Paul Pierson’s political science research calls it “policy feedback.” The practical implication is that conservation advocates should think carefully about who benefits from a program or designation, how quickly those benefits materialize, and how those beneficiaries are connected to the political process.

LWCF and Farm Bill Programs are apt illustrations of this phenomenon. In the case of LWCF, land acquisitions that are high priority for state and local communities and conservation groups generate their own constituency. When the second Trump administration proposed diverting LWCF funds in 2025, the Coalition mobilized this entire network in defense of a funding mechanism that serves constituencies across the partisan spectrum.

With respect to the Farm Bill, some Congressional Republicans initially signaled their interest immediately following passage of the Inflation Reductions Act of 2022 to divert new dollars for conservation programs to farm commodity support programs. But, after those conservation programs proved very popular among farmers, ranchers and forest owners– even with restrictions that the new dollars be used for climate smart practices – Republicans softened their stance. When the Trump Administration and Congress were working to unwind and defund the Inflation Reduction Act’s climate funding in 2025, Congress – led by the Republican Chair of the House Agriculture Committee — reallocated unspent IRA climate smart conservation dollars in such a way that those dollars have now permanently increased resources for Farm Bill conservation programs, albeit without the requirements for spending them on climate smart practices.

Part IV: Plan for Implementation

The fourth and most often neglected element of durable conservation is implementation. A brilliant policy design and a broad stakeholder coalition can both be undone by implementation failure—and implementation failure is often a failure to plan for the staff capacity, funding, and institutional infrastructure needed to deliver results on the ground. When implementation of conservation programs and policies is poor, stakeholder and political support for those programs and conservation more broadly can suffer.

“There are three parts of durability: process, content, and implementation. The process has to actively engage people and the results must reflect what emerged through the process. And, then you need to deliver on outcomes. You build durability through your actions.” —Meryl Harrell, former USDA Deputy Under Secretary

Most conservation planning focuses heavily on process and content—who to engage, what to protect, how to structure the legal protection. Implementation—how the protection will actually be delivered on the ground, by whom, funded how—tends to receive less attention. This can be a strategic error, because implementation failure can diminish political support for conservation policy, programs and initiatives, whereas implementation success can ensure support, tangible benefits, and long-term durability.

Agency Capacity and Commitment Is Critical

Federal agency staff and federal resources shared with local conservation partners are the indispensable delivery mechanism for most conservation programs. The Sage Grouse Initiative deploys more than twenty field positions, jointly funded by SGI and partners such as Pheasants Forever, in rural communities across eleven states. These “boots on the ground”—range and wildlife conservationists stationed in Malta, Montana, and Ely, Nevada, and dozens of similar places—are what make SGI’s kitchen-table conversations with ranchers possible. The Joint Chiefs’ Landscape Restoration Partnership, which since 2014 has invested more than $423 million in 134 projects across 42 states, works precisely because NRCS and Forest Service field offices develop projects collaboratively with local partners—not because Washington headquarters designs programs from above.

Jess Wahl Turner, of the Outdoor Recreation Roundtable, emphasizes that having advocates within federal agencies for specific conservation programs is critical to durability. When a program has motivated and committed staff—people whose careers and relationships are invested in its success—it is far more likely to survive administrative transitions than programs that exist only as policy documents.

Wendi Weber, who spent nearly three decades in the US Fish and Wildlife Service including over a decade as a Regional Director and as a Deputy Director, emphasizes the importance of staff dedication to the success of federal conservation policies and programs. According to Weber, having the right people in the agency “with a commitment to a collaborative culture” towards implementing the policy or project is fundamental to its success.

Funding is critical to agency capacity. When Congress considers LWCF, Farm Bill conservation programs or other conservation programs, funding remains a priority of advocates. But, advocates often forget that agency capacity is required to implement those and other programs. Most federal conservation agencies are stretched thin. The National Park Service has an enormous infrastructure backlog. Forest Service budgets are increasingly consumed by firefighting. NRCS lacks funding for technical assistance and outreach.

Funding challenges also manifest themselves in specific projects. As noted previously, the Katahdin Woods and Water National Monument benefited from private funding during implementation. Other monuments reliant on Forest Service and BLM funding typically don’t receive new funding, meaning agencies have to move or cut funding from other programs to fund needed conservation, recreation or other activities. This not only hampers management of these sites, it creates resistance within federal agencies for unfunded initiatives, whether its a monument designation or some other project.

Bureaucratic Red Tape Undermines Conservation Durability

Multiple interviewees independently raised the obstacle of excessive bureaucratic process as a deterrent to conservation success. Tommy Beaudreau notes that “red tape, bureaucratic processes and fear of litigation have hampered projects on private lands.” Providing another example, Bruce Knight argues that NRCS’s revision process of its conservation standards (that guide actions on participating lands) is too slow and needs to be more flexible to respond to rapidly changing ecological and economic conditions. Taylor Schmitz notes that “overly bureaucratic processes, red tape, and lack of quick engagement by federal agencies” are deterrents to successful conservation implementation.

Jimmy Bullock puts the challenge directly: “Turn loose of the old ways.” Conservation implementation needs to be as innovative and adaptive as the ecosystems it seeks to protect. When federal agencies take years to process routine conservation agreements or permits, they erode trust and discourage the private landowners and local partners whose participation is essential to conservation at scale. Streamlining processes—without sacrificing accountability —is not a concession to conservation opponents. It is a prerequisite for building the private landowner relationships that durable conservation requires.

Landowner assurances under the Endangered Species Act, developed initially in the mid-1990s through such tools as safe harbor agreements and candidate conservation agreements with assurances, have evolved significantly in the intervening years. Landowners have increasingly steered away from habitat conservation plans because they take years to develop and are perceived as being intrusive. More flexible agreements developed by the US Fish and Wildlife Service have encouraged new partnerships and proactive management that has moved millions of acres into proactive conservation.

A similar story has played out on National Forests as the development of stewardship agreements, Good Neighbor Authority, and shared stewardship agreements over the last two decades have increased forest restoration treatments across federal, state and tribal lands. These tools have reduced bureaucratic friction and brought in additional partners and resources, allowing larger treatment areas.

There is more work to do. NRCS, for example, has begun the process of streamlining its conservation easement programs by partnering with local land trusts, but easements often still take too long, dissuading farmers and ranchers from participating. More flexible approaches can also help conservation policies adapt over time. Tim Male, CEO of the Environmental Policy Innovation Center, notes that built-in policy flexibility makes it easier for successive administrations to adapt conservation policies to their priorities and approaches which in itself contributes to durability.

Delays from bureaucratic red-tape become even more consequential in the face of climate change. Delayed forest management projects on National Forests that, for example, restore fire-suppressed Ponderosa pine forests through thinning and reintroduction of 16 low-intensity fires increases the potential loss of old growth pines due to unnaturally destructive wildfires. Likewise, delays in approving coastal wetland restoration can mean permanent habitat losses should a catastrophic hurricane land in the area. In conservation, time is often of the essence.

Place-Based Collaborative Governance

One of the most effective implementation models identified in this research is place-based collaborative governance: organizations rooted in specific landscapes that bring together landowners, agencies, conservation groups, and community members around a shared commitment to the health of that place.

The Blackfoot Challenge in Montana is the archetype. Formally established in 1993—though rooted in landowner relationships going back to the 1970s—the Challenge brings together every public agency that manages land in the Blackfoot watershed alongside private landowners, local business owners, conservation NGOs, and other watershed residents. Designed as a collaborative effort for weed management, water conservation, wildlife management, and sustainable forestry, the initiative is built upon mutual respect, a sense that all major stakeholders have to have a seat at the table, and a guiding principle – the 80:20 rule. Stakeholders work on the 80% of issues they can agree upon and leave the other 20% at the door. This consensus-driven, non-advocacy approach has been spearheaded by local residents– many of whom including ranch owners and Blackfoot Challenge Board Members Jim Stone and Denny Iverson, have become key spokespeople for the effort, and its results over thirty years are remarkable: 91,000 acres of private land protected through conservation easements, thousands of acres of wetlands rehabilitated, dozens of tributaries restored, and the Blackfoot River transformed from one of the most at-risk watersheds in the country into one of Montana’s foremost trout fishing destinations.

What makes the Blackfoot Challenge a model for implementation—rather than merely a model for coalition-building—is its capacity to deliver results on the ground year after year, independent of changes in federal or state administration. Because the Challenge is rooted in the community and funded by a diverse mix of public and private sources, it does not depend on any single political champion or any single funding stream for its survival. It has survived administrations of both parties and budget cycles of both feast and famine because its work is valued by the people it serves directly.

Durable Policy Implementation

In the case of conservation policy, establishing an administrative home for policy implementation that is both effective and durable is critical. The Sage Grouse Task Force was established in 2011 by the-Secretary of Interior Ken Salazar to address the proposed listing of the bird. Members included federal land management agencies and the 11 affected western states. The Task Force played a critical role in amending federal land management plans and undertaking other actions that resulted in the species avoiding listing. The Task Force gave Governors a powerful voice, diffused what could have otherwise been a far more contentious process, and carried on activities into the first Trump Administration.

A diverse committee also helped with implementation of the US Forest Service’s Planning Rule, which governs management of the National Forest System, when the Obama Administration rewrote it in 2012. The National Advisory Committee for the Implementation of the National Forest System Land Management Planning Rule was composed of 21 members from conservation, forest industry, agriculture, tribes, local government, outdoor recreation and youth. The Committee was tasked with developing recommendations for proposed Forest Service directives that would implement the rule. Implementation of the rule in the field has been uneven but the committee was critical in building broader support for the rule among diverse constituencies and in developing Forest Service guidance that was largely non-controversial.

In each case, conservation advocates, landowner groups and other interests worked closely with the government officials to implement conservation strategies for the sage grouse and the National Forest System. And, given the different interests and potential for controversy in these two examples, these processes likely avoided significant conflict that might have otherwise made implementation of conservation actions more difficult.

Conclusion: Durability as Strategy

The framework offered here is not complicated. But it does require that we focus on what’s working, challenge ourselves to rethink approaches and shift the culture and identity of what it means to “win” at conservation in the United States. Designing conservation policies, programs and initiatives to last over the long term requires building conservation actions that align with stakeholders’ values, that have a strong economic rational, that are supported by a broad, bipartisan, diverse coalition, that are designed in a way that maintains or – better yet – generates a broad base of support and that have the staffing, partners, and financial support to last.

The cases examined in this paper demonstrate that these principles are not just aspirational—they are achievable and replicable. Durability does not happen by accident, by the force of good science alone, or by the passion of committed advocates. It requires the patient work of building relationships, the discipline of designing for breadth rather than purity, and the strategic foresight to invest in institutions and communities. That work is harder than winning a single legislative battle or policy campaign. But it is the work that produces conservation that lasts.

Note on Sources

The analysis in this paper draws on original interviews conducted with Tommy Beaudreau, Tim Bristol, Jimmy Bullock, Suzanne Dixon, Meryl Harrell, Andrea Keller Helsel, Bruce Knight, Rick Johnson, Tim Male, David O’Neill, Christy Plumer, Will Shafroth, Lindsay Slater, Amy Sobel, HeatherDawn Thompson, Taylor Schmitz, Adam Snyder, Jess Wahl Turner, Wendi Weber, and Homer Wilkes; on case study research into the conservation programs and designations referenced throughout; and on peer-reviewed academic research including work by Paul Pierson on policy feedback theory, Elinor Ostrom on institutional design principles, and others.